In recent months, talk of regulating or even breaking up Amazon.com, Inc. has moved from the political fringes to the mainstream. In early March, in a widely discussed Medium post, Democratic presidential candidate Senator Elizabeth Warren made the case that Amazon (plus Google and Facebook) have amassed an alarming concentration of power, arguing for structural change to the tech industry.
Even if the Massachusetts senator’s call to break up Amazon is mostly aspirational right now, it’s not hard to see why Warren felt justified in putting the Seattle leviathan on her list of targets. Perhaps more than any other U.S. technology company, Amazon has come to resemble a conglomerate, with a growing presence in multiple markets.
The company is best known as the world’s largest online store. But of course Amazon is much more than that. It sells advertising on its website, making the company a small but growing rival to Facebook and Google. Amazon is a hardware maker, with an expanding line of smart speakers and video streaming gadgets. Amazon Studios makes original television shows and movies and is starting to steal awards from Netflix and HBO. With its acquisition of Whole Foods Market and a growing fleet of cashierless convenience stores, Amazon has sowed fear among traditional grocers. And in perhaps the most surprising development of all, Amazon has become the world’s biggest provider of cloud-computing services.
Based on the current interpretation of U.S. antitrust law—which focuses on harm to consumers via predatory pricing—there’s little to suggest that such a corporate arrangement is illegal. Amazon, after all, preaches an almost maniacal focus on consumers and for decades has generally hewed to a core mission of offering customers more selection at lower prices.
When confronted with calls for antitrust scrutiny, Amazon has stressed a few points that, strictly speaking, ring true. The company’s broad reach is not on its own an indication of market power. In just about every market Amazon has entered, it encounters well entrenched competitors, including some retailers who are finding success by blurring the line between online and offline commerce.
And despite being the largest e-commerce player, Amazon still accounts for roughly 1 percent of global retail. In the U.S., the company's share of all retail sales is as high as 7.7 percent, including sales made by other retailers who sell on Amazon's Marketplace. Absent that, Amazon itself accounts for less than 3 percent of U.S. retail sales, according to Euromonitor International.
All the same, size and reach put the company in a class of its own—ensuring that in this populist age Amazon will continue to be a target of would-be trustbusters like Warren. And to think it all began with books—the paper kind that arrived in a box at the front door.
To a young Jeff Bezos, books were a commodity. Copies of a novel sold at Barnes & Noble were identical to the ones stocked by an independent bookstore. And by shipping books from distributors or Amazon's essentially endless warehouse space, the company's digital storefront could offer a wider selection than any brick-and-mortar store.
Books
807M
unit sales
42%
Amazon
58%
Others
E-Books
560M
unit sales
89%
Amazon
6.3% Apple
4.8% Others
E-Books
560M
unit sales
Books
807M
unit sales
42%
Amazon
89%
Amazon
58%
Others
6.3% Apple
4.8% Others
E-Books
560M
unit sales
Books
807M
unit sales
42%
Amazon
89%
Amazon
58%
Others
6.3% Apple
4.8% Others
In the late 1990s, Amazon expanded into other commoditized media products, starting with music and movies. Electronics and toys followed. By the mid-2000s, Amazon’s growing network of warehouses also held kitchen items, sporting goods, video games, apparel and jewelry.
E-Commerce
$524B
total sales
45% Amazon
6.8% eBay
4.0% Walmart
3.8% Apple
1.6% Home Depot
1.3% Best Buy
1.3% Macy’s
33% Others
1.2% Qurate
Retail Group
1.1% Costco
1.1% Wayfair
E-Commerce
$524B
total sales
45% Amazon
6.8% eBay
4.0% Walmart
3.8% Apple
1.6% Home
Depot
1.3% Best Buy
1.3% Macy’s
1.2% Qurate
Retail Group
1.1% Costco
1.1% Wayfair
33% Others
E-Commerce
$524B
total sales
45% Amazon
4.0% Walmart
3.8% Apple
1.6% Home Depot
1.3% Best Buy
1.3% Macy’s
1.2% Qurate Retail Group
1.1% Costco
1.1% Wayfair
6.8% eBay
33% Others
As Amazon grew, the company adopted a business school concept called the flywheel, loosely defined as a sort of self-reinforcing loop. Where possible, projects were to be structured to bolster other initiatives underway at the company.
For Amazon’s core in retail, the formula held that lower prices and wide selection would draw shoppers to Amazon.com, leading to more purchases, giving Amazon more leverage to negotiate even lower prices from manufacturers. That, in turn, would enable Amazon to offer even lower prices and broader selection.
In 2000, Amazon launched Marketplace, offering other merchants the option to pay to list their wares on Amazon’s digital shelves and, later, stock them in the company’s own warehouses, a decision that would dramatically increase Amazon’s own selection without tying up the company’s cash in inventory of iPhone cases and DVDs.
BOOKS, MUSIC &
VIDEO
80%
TOYS & HOBBY 62%
CONSUMER
ELECTRONICS
57%
52%
OTHER
CATEGORIES
OFFICE
EQUIPMENT &
SUPPLIES
51%
FURNITURE &
HOME GOODS
46%
HEALTH,
PERSONAL
CARE & BEAUTY
44%
39%
APPAREL &
ACCESSORIES
FOOD &
BEVERAGE
32%
AUTO PARTS 16%
BOOKS, MUSIC, VIDEO 80%
TOYS & HOBBY 62%
CONSUMER ELECTRONICS 57%
OTHER CATEGORIES 52%
OFFICE EQUIPMENT &
SUPPLIES
51%
FURNITURE & HOME GOODS 46%
HEALTH, PERSONAL CARE &
BEAUTY
44%
APPAREL & ACCESSORIES 39%
FOOD & BEVERAGE 32%
AUTO PARTS 16%
BOOKS, MUSIC, VIDEO 80%
TOYS & HOBBY 62%
CONSUMER ELECTRONICS 57%
OTHER CATEGORIES 52%
OFFICE EQUIPMENT & SUPPLIES 51%
FURNITURE & HOME GOODS 46%
HEALTH, PERSONAL CARE, BEAUTY 44%
APPAREL & ACCESSORIES 39%
FOOD & BEVERAGE 32%
AUTO PARTS 16%
But as Amazon painstakingly expanded the categories of goods it stocked, for most people, the company remained a bookstore first.
Then in 2005, Amazon rolled out the Prime membership program, offering, in exchange for an annual fee, quicker shipping on a selection of items in its inventory. The program, over time, helped nudge customers who might have only used Amazon for books and movies to browse other categories of goods. After all, after that initial payment, shipping was free.
Prime today boasts more than 100 million paying members, making it among the world's largest paid membership programs.